Thursday, March 5, 2020

Blog #1- Insane Asylums In the Early 19th Century


Image result for insane asylums in the early 19th century
   Insane Asylums were much different in the 19th century than they are today. How well a patient was taken care of depended on what they could afford. If the patient was wealthier they could afford a smaller private asylum where the treatment was better and more personal to them. However for the vast majority of the patients that needed treatment, they had to check into a public hospital or large asylum that wasn't of the best quality. The hospitals were over crowded and extremely dirty. The windows had bars on them and because the nurses weren't paid well, the patients were often treated harshly.


Most physicians assumed that the mental illnesses and cases being brought into the hospital were caused by the nervous system. For this reason the patients were treated by using tactics such as hydro-therapy, electrical stimulation, and rest. A small number of the doctors abandoned the idea of the nervous system being the cause such as a man named Boris Sidis. Sidis recieved his Phd from Harvard and medical degree shortly after. He argued that the cause of the mental disorders was from the consciousness itself, the "data" of psychology and the subconscious as well. For this reason he used a form of hypnosis to gain conscious memories from his patients. When the patient would wake he would describe their memories to them thus curing them.

Image result for insane asylums in the early 19th century
   Closer to the 1800s people used mentally ill people and observing them as an odd form of entertainment in the victorian era. Over time however the reality and danger became more prominent to the people and they no longer used it as a form of entertainment, but instead used it as a way to understand the medicine and treatments to educate themselves. Moving into the early 19th century, doctors came to realize that the privacy of the patients aided them in their recovery process and the tourism thus disappeared.

Image result for victorian asylums
   When you think of asylums you think immediately that the patients were tortured and no one was treated properly, but as time passed the conditions gradually grew to a better state. As early as the 1800s physicians started realizing the best way to get their patients to recover was to treat them as ordinary people. They started to tailor to the patients and put patients with the same conditions in the same grouping. They even added birds and parrots in cages to brighten the atmosphere for the patients. Yes not everyone was taken care of the best they could have been, but going from the 1800s into the 1900s provided better care as the realization of the severity of mental health rose.






Box, Christy. “19th-Century Tourists Visited Mental Asylums Like They Were Theme Parks.” Ranker, 2 May 2019, www.ranker.com/list/asylum-visitors-in-the-nineteenth-century/christy-box.


Holtzman, Ellen. Monitor on Psychology, American Psychological Association, Mar. 2012, www.apa.org/monitor/2012/03/asylums.

Stevens, Mark. Life in the Victorian Asylum : The World of Nineteenth Century Mental Health Care. 2014. Web.


“A Victorian Mental Asylum.” Science Museum, 13 June 2018, www.sciencemuseum.org.uk/objects-and-stories/victorian-mental-asylum.




2 comments:

  1. I already had a general sense of the tragic state of asylums in the early nineteenth century from Psychology 101, but your blog did reinforce these ideas in a powerful way. While improvements certainly have been made, I feel as though these problems still prevalent to a certain degree today. Just as the Victorian people were fascinated by the asylum patients, many of us today are still drawn to the unusual and absurd, just in a less public way. Similarly, as rich people received better treatment, wealthy people are certainly more privileged in many ways today.

    ReplyDelete
  2. This was had interesting look into the insane asylums over the years. People today would judge how awful these asylums where and how much improved in treatment and recover facilities today. This may be true, but we also have step back from the our privilege of knowledge on looking upon the past. At that time, they deemed the treatments as fit, based on the knowledge back then. Instead of just criticizing the past, we as humans beings need to know how to move forward and learn from previous mistakes, because surely future generations are going judge us, so we need to learn to move forward and improve society as best we can in our circumstances.

    ReplyDelete